When it comes to choosing paint for your next project, two brands often dominate the conversation: Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore. Both have loyal followings and are renowned for their quality, but which one reigns supreme? Let’s explore opinions and insights from Reddit and other online sources to help you make an informed decision. Keep in Mind, Majestic Painting has preferred pricing on both brands and happy with both!
Overview of the SHERWIN-WILLIAMS & BENJAMIN MOORE Brands
Sherwin-Williams
- Founded: 1866
- Reputation: Known for its wide range of colors and finishes, durability, and accessibility.
- Products: Offers a variety of paints for both interior and exterior applications, along with primers and stains.
Benjamin Moore
- Founded: 1883
- Reputation: Celebrated for its rich pigments and sm
- ooth application. It often ranks high in terms of coverage and finish.
- Products: Offers a premium line of paints, including eco-friendly options, and a vast color palette.
Reddit Insights: What Are Users Saying?
Color Selection
Many Reddit users highlight that both brands excel in color variety, but opinions differ on the vibrancy and depth of colors.
- Sherwin-Williams: Users appreciate the ease of finding trendy colors and the extensive collections, such as the Emerald line.
- Benjamin Moore: Fans praise Benjamin Moore for its unique hues and exceptional depth, especially in their Regal line.
Coverage and Application
When it comes to application, there are mixed feelings:
- Sherwin-Williams: Some users argue that Sherwin-Williams paints tend to have better coverage in fewer coats, particularly with their SuperPaint line.
- Benjamin Moore: Others counter that Benjamin Moore provides a smoother finish and is easier to work with, especially for DIYers.
Price Point
Price is often a decisive factor for many homeowners:
- Sherwin-Williams: Generally, their paints can be less expensive, especially with frequent promotions and sales.
- Benjamin Moore: While typically pricier, many users believe the quality justifies the cost, stating that it often requires fewer coats.
Performance and Durability
Both brands boast durable products, but user experiences vary:
- Sherwin-Williams: Users often commend their exterior paints for weather resistance, making them ideal for harsher climates.
- Benjamin Moore: Many cite its interior paints as particularly washable and resistant to stains, which is great for families with kids or pets.
Final Verdict: Which Should You Choose?
Ultimately, the choice between Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore may come down to personal preference and project needs. Here are a few final considerations:
| Factor | Sherwin-Williams | Benjamin Moore |
|---|---|---|
| Color Variety | Wide range, trendy options | Unique hues, rich pigments |
| Coverage | Generally good with fewer coats | Excellent finish, smooth application |
| Price | Typically more affordable | Higher price point, but quality valued |
| Durability | Great for exteriors, resistant | Excellent for interiors, washable |
Conclusion
Whether you lean towards Sherwin-Williams or Benjamin Moore, both brands have their strengths. Consider your specific needs, budget, and preferences, and don’t hesitate to test samples from both to see which one resonates with you. Happy painting!